Skip to main content
You can run several Live trading strategies on the same instrument in the same broker account — a breakout and a mean-reversion strategy both trading ES, in the one account — and keep trading that account by hand alongside them.
This is an advanced setup. Nothing about it is harder to switch on — you just turn Live trading on for a second strategy — but it changes what your broker screen means, what your statement’s P&L means, and what happens when you place a trade yourself. Read this page before you do it.

​
Why it needs explaining: your broker nets

Your broker keeps one position record per account and contract. It does not know about strategies, and there is no broker-side field that says “one of these two ES contracts belongs to the breakout strategy.” Orders, on the other hand, are separable: every order Live trading sends carries a tag identifying the strategy that sent it, so every fill is routed back to the right one. That is how Live trading keeps per-strategy books over a netted broker position, and it gives one identity that the whole feature is arranged around:
Each strategy’s share is built from its own fills — never from the broker’s netted number, which with two strategies on a contract is nobody’s single position. The last term, the residual, is defined as whatever is left over. It is your own trading, and defining it as the remainder is what lets Live trading recompute it correctly after any disconnect, without needing to see your manual fills.

​
Reading it on the Positions page

Under each symbol you get: A standing “your own position” is information, not an alarm — Live trading has acknowledged it as your baseline. It only turns amber when it is unexplained: a question is open about the trade that changed it. The run view shows the same split for a strategy whenever the account holds more than that one strategy.

​
What changes when you do this

The broker nets the strategies together and reports the net. If one is long and another short, its realised P&L belongs to neither of them. Per-strategy P&L comes from AskFutures’ own record of each strategy’s fills — the Positions page states this caveat wherever two strategies share an account.
Two strategies that want opposite positions each send their own orders and each rest their own brackets. At the broker they may net to zero while both strategies are still holding — and being managed — perfectly correctly. Live trading does not collapse them into one net order.
The contracts-per-signal limit is per strategy. Your account’s worst case is the sum of every Live trading strategy’s size on it. Three strategies at 2 contracts each can put you at 6 contracts of one-way exposure. Check that against your margin before you turn the second one on — nothing in AskFutures checks it for you.
The demo gate is per strategy. A new strategy does its own clean demo day even if a sibling has been trading live for weeks. Two strategies on one demo account is, in fact, the right rehearsal for this whole feature.

​
When you also trade the account by hand

This is the part that matters most, and it applies whether you run one Live trading strategy or five.

​
A standing position is fine

If you already hold ES by hand and then put a strategy on that account, nothing is asked and nothing is disturbed. The position you were already holding becomes the baseline, and Live trading simply works around it. The same is true when it restarts into an account holding your positions.

​
A change is what raises a question

If the account’s position moves in a way no strategy’s orders explain — you bought or sold the instrument yourself — and strategies have positions or working orders at stake, Live trading first waits briefly to see whether one of their own orders explains it. If none does, it acts, and then it asks. What happens immediately, before you answer:

​
The question

One question per account and contract — not one per strategy — reaches you on your usual alert channels and as a card at the top of the Positions page and on each affected run view:
Did you sell 1 ES yourself? A trade AskFutures did not send sold 1 ES on your account. Until you say whose it was, the strategies below are held — no new entries go out.
It lists each affected strategy, what Live trading attributes to it, and whether its exits were cancelled. You answer one of three ways:
Reading the question is never gated. Answering it is — it is an action that restarts trading. And while a question is open, Match strategy and Skip this trade are both refused for the affected strategies: neither could keep the promise it makes until the account’s books are settled.

​
If you don’t answer

A question left unanswered for 10 minutes of market-open time resolves itself — counted in open-market time, so one raised just before the close does not quietly expire overnight.Each affected strategy then assumes its share of your trade closed its position, oldest first, re-places protective exits for whatever it still believes it holds, and halts for you to resume. The assumption is written down alongside the trades that prompted it, so you can always see what was guessed.It deliberately does not flatten what is left. After an unanswered closing trade the attribution is a guess, and selling against a guess — into an account you may have already flattened yourself — would put you net short. Halting with protection in place is the safe end of that branch, not the tidy one.
A second manual trade while a question is open replaces the question: the containment is re-applied against the new trade and the clock restarts.

​
Practical advice

  • Add the second strategy in demo and let it run a day beside the first, even if you’re impatient. That day is where you find out what the two of them together actually do to the account.
  • Do your manual trading somewhere else if you can. A separate account for discretionary trades removes this entire category of question.
  • If you do trade the account by hand, answer the question promptly. Between the trade and your answer, the strategies on that side are holding positions with their stops cancelled.
  • Size for the sum, not the parts. Your margin sees Σ of every strategy’s contracts.
  • Read per-strategy P&L in AskFutures, not on your statement.

​
Next steps

Positions and controls

Where the split, the question and the kill switches all live.

When things go sideways

The per-strategy settings around all of this.